Choosing the right butter dish can enhance your kitchen experience in more ways than one. A good butter dish not only keeps your butter fresh but also adds a touch of style to your countertop. With so many options available, you might find it challenging to select the best one for your needs. This guide will help you discover the top-rated butter dishes that come with knives, making your butter storage both convenient and aesthetically pleasing.
Top Picks
- Best Overall: Butter Dish with Lid by Qalveris
- Best Value: Ceramic Butter Dish by GMYIAK
- Best Design: Butter Dish with Lid by AISBUGUR
- Best for Large Capacity: Ceramic Butter Dish with Wooden Lid by Lxmons
- Best Plastic Option: KITCHENDAO Airtight Flip-Top Butter Dish
How We Selected the Best Butter Dishes
When selecting a butter dish, consider factors such as material, design, capacity, and ease of cleaning. A good butter dish should keep your butter fresh while being easy to use and maintain. Look for features like a lid, included knife, and a design that complements your kitchen decor.
Butter Dish with Lid
This butter dish is not just a pretty face; it’s a practical addition to your kitchen. With its sleek dark blue design, it fits perfectly on your countertop while keeping your butter fresh. The high-quality silicone sealing and wooden lid ensure that your butter stays soft and spreadable, whether you’re using it for breakfast or a special dinner. Plus, it comes with a knife, making it super convenient for serving. Whether you’re hosting a brunch or just enjoying a quiet morning, this butter dish is a must-have.
What People Say
Users appreciate the beautiful design and functionality of this butter dish. Many have noted how it keeps butter fresh and easy to spread, making it a favorite for both everyday use and special occasions.
- I bought this product as a gift for Christmas for my mother-in-law. She loved it. The design is very pleasing, the color wonderful.
– Amazon Customer
- Cute as can be. Large. Holds two sticks of butter side by side.
– kjkj23
Why You’ll Love It
- High-quality materials for durability
- Easy to clean ceramic surface
- Large capacity for multiple butter sticks
- Stylish design that complements any kitchen decor
- Includes a knife for easy serving
Ideal For Any Occasion
Perfect for both casual breakfasts and elegant dinner parties, this butter dish adds a touch of charm to any table setting. It’s also a great gift for housewarmings or weddings.
Rating: 5 (Total: 2+)
Ceramic Butter Dish with Knife
This ceramic butter dish is a delightful blend of style and functionality. Designed to hold up to two sticks of butter, it keeps your butter at room temperature while protecting it from light and air. The unique lid features a groove for easy access to the included stainless steel knife, making it a breeze to serve. Whether you’re spreading butter on toast for breakfast or adding a touch of elegance to your dinner table, this butter dish is a charming addition to your kitchen. Plus, its easy-to-clean surface means you can spend less time in the kitchen and more time enjoying your meals.
What People Say
Users rave about the practical design and how well it keeps butter fresh. Many appreciate the included knife and the stylish look that fits seamlessly into any kitchen decor.
- I love this butter dish. It holds 8 ounces of butter easily and it’s deep enough the top doesn’t touch the butter so it doesn’t get messy. The knife is perfect.
– Claudia L Kidwell
- I was worried this would take up too much counter space, but I love it so much that I don’t mind. It’s ceramic design and tight fitting lid help keep my butter fresh.
– R.
Why You’ll Love It
- Durable ceramic construction for long-lasting use
- Includes a stainless steel knife for easy serving
- Unique lid design with a groove for the knife
- Keeps butter fresh and spreadable at room temperature
- Easy to clean and maintain
Ideal For Any Occasion
This butter dish is perfect for everyday breakfasts or special occasions. It also makes a thoughtful gift for friends and family who love to entertain or enjoy cooking.
Rating: 5 (Total: 8+)
Butter Dish with Lid
This large ceramic butter dish is not just a pretty face; it’s designed to hold two sticks of butter while keeping them fresh and spreadable. The lid features a clever groove for the included stainless steel knife, making it easy to serve your butter without any mess. Whether you’re hosting a brunch or just enjoying a quiet breakfast at home, this butter dish adds a touch of elegance to your countertop. Plus, it’s easy to clean, so you can spend more time enjoying your meals and less time worrying about cleanup.
What People Say
Users appreciate the thoughtful design and how well it keeps butter fresh. The included knife is a hit, and many love the stylish look that fits seamlessly into their kitchen.
- This is exactly what I was looking for to complement my black and tan kitchen. I like keeping butter near the stove so that it is room temperature, but I hated the look of a tub of butter sitting there looking like an advertisement. This is perfect. I keep two sticks at a time in the dish, but you can fit 4 if you like. I love that it comes with a top that conveniently stores the butter knife. The tub is ceramic, and the top is wood. Very sturdy.
– Miz Dee
Why You’ll Love It
- Upgraded super capacity to hold various butter stick shapes
- Excellent sealing performance to maintain freshness
- Safe for use in ovens, microwaves, and dishwashers
- Stylish design that complements any kitchen decor
- Multi-functional for storing other ingredients too
Ideal For Any Occasion
This butter dish is perfect for everyday use or special occasions. It also makes a lovely gift for anyone who enjoys cooking or entertaining.
Rating: 4.8 (Total: 5261+)
Ceramic Butter Dish with Wooden Lid
This charming ceramic butter dish is designed to keep your butter fresh and easily spreadable. With a spacious interior that holds up to two standard sticks of butter, it’s perfect for both everyday use and special occasions. The bamboo lid not only seals in freshness but also doubles as a cutting board, making it a practical addition to your kitchen. Plus, the included stainless steel knife fits neatly into a groove on the lid, ensuring you always have the right tool at hand. Whether you’re hosting a dinner party or just enjoying a quiet breakfast, this butter dish adds a touch of elegance to your countertop.
What People Say
Users rave about how well this butter dish keeps butter fresh and the convenience of the built-in knife. Many appreciate its stylish design, which fits beautifully in their kitchens.
- This dish easily holds two full sticks of butter. I gave it to my daughter, and she was very pleased to have it for her family who uses a fair amount of butter daily. The cover is useful with its built-in butter knife. The dish should not be picked up by the top, however, because the seal is not strong enough to hold the dish. The bottom of the dish can easily be cleaned in the dishwasher. It has a neat clean appearance.
– Linda Whitcomb
Why You’ll Love It
- Large capacity to hold two sticks of butter
- Bamboo lid with sealing ring to maintain freshness
- High-quality, chip-resistant porcelain
- Built-in stainless steel knife for easy spreading
- Stylish farmhouse design that enhances kitchen decor
Perfect For Any Occasion
This butter dish is ideal for daily use or special gatherings. It also makes a thoughtful gift for anyone who enjoys cooking or entertaining.
Rating: 4.8 (Total: 6127+)
KITCHENDAO Airtight Flip-Top Butter Dish with Knife
The KITCHENDAO Airtight Flip-Top Butter Dish is a game changer for butter lovers. Designed to hold two sticks of butter, this dish keeps your butter fresh and spreadable, whether it’s sitting on your countertop or tucked away in the fridge. The flip-top lid is not just convenient; it also prevents butter from getting stuck on the lid, which is a common annoyance with traditional butter dishes. Plus, the built-in knife is a thoughtful touch, ensuring you always have a clean tool ready for spreading. This butter dish is perfect for everyday use, but it also shines during special occasions when you want to impress your guests with a stylish and functional kitchen accessory.
What People Say
Users appreciate how well this butter dish keeps their butter fresh and the convenience of the built-in knife. Many love its sleek design, which fits beautifully in their kitchens.
- I always leave my butter on the counter but hate it when others leave the lid off. This dish has a hinged lid and space for up to 2 quarters, plus the included butter knife fits inside! Easy to wash and no more mess on the counter. The butter is also protected from flies. I’m going to buy this as a gift as well.
– Merrilan Kougias
Why You’ll Love It
- Airtight design keeps butter fresh and protected
- Built-in knife stored neatly inside the dish
- Easy to clean and dishwasher safe
- Large capacity for two sticks of butter
- Stylish and functional for any kitchen decor
Perfect For Any Occasion
This butter dish is perfect for daily use or special gatherings. It’s also a thoughtful gift for anyone who enjoys cooking or entertaining.
Rating: 4.8 (Total: 180+)
FAQ
What should I consider when buying a butter dish with a knife?
When you’re looking for a butter dish with a knife, think about the size and capacity. You want one that can comfortably hold the amount of butter you typically use, whether that’s one or two sticks. Also, consider the material; ceramic dishes tend to keep butter fresh longer, while plastic options are often lighter and easier to clean. Look for features like a lid that seals well to keep your butter protected from air and light, and check if the knife is included and how it’s stored. A design that allows easy access to the knife is a plus.
How do I properly clean and maintain my butter dish?
To keep your butter dish in great shape, follow the manufacturer’s care instructions. Most ceramic dishes are hand wash only, while some plastic ones may be dishwasher safe. Always dry your dish thoroughly after washing to prevent any moisture buildup. If your butter dish has a silicone seal, make sure to check it regularly for wear and tear, as a good seal is essential for keeping your butter fresh. If you notice any odors or stains, a gentle scrub with baking soda can help restore its appearance.
Can I store my butter dish in the refrigerator, or should it stay on the countertop?
You can store your butter dish on the countertop or in the refrigerator, depending on your preference and how quickly you use butter. If you prefer soft butter for spreading, keeping it on the counter is ideal, especially if your dish has a good seal to protect it from contaminants. However, if you live in a warmer climate or don’t use butter often, storing it in the refrigerator can help maintain its freshness. Just remember that cold butter can be hard to spread, so you might want to take it out a little while before you need it.
Wrapping Up
Investing in a quality butter dish can significantly improve your kitchen experience. Not only do these dishes keep your butter fresh and easily accessible, but they also add a stylish touch to your countertop. Whether you prefer ceramic, plastic, or a unique design, there is a butter dish that will meet your needs and enhance your culinary space.
| Product | Image | Rating | Highlights | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Butter Dish With Lid |
 |
5/5 (2 ratings) | Large butter container with lid, high-quality silicone sealing, ceramic material. | Stylish design, holds two sticks of butter, easy to clean. | Hand wash only. |
| Ceramic Butter Dish |
 |
5/5 (8 ratings) | Durable ceramic, includes stainless steel knife, acacia wood lid. | Keeps butter fresh, easy to access knife, elegant design. | Not suitable for dishwasher. |
| Butter Dish With Lid |
 |
4.8/5 (5,261 ratings) | Large ceramic holder, perfect for two sticks of butter, includes knife. | Stylish, sturdy, multiple color options. | Doesn’t fit 1 lb of butter as claimed. |
| Ceramic Butter Dish With Wooden Lid |
 |
4.8/5 (6,127 ratings) | Includes stainless steel knife, bamboo cover, silicone sealing ring. | Holds two sticks of butter, elegant design, easy to clean. | Seal may not hold if lifted by the lid. |
| KITCHENDAO Airtight Butter Dish |
 |
4.8/5 (180 ratings) | Plastic butter holder with lid and knife, dishwasher safe. | Easy to clean, protects butter from flies, includes knife. | Plastic may not be as durable as ceramic. |
This Roundup is reader-supported. When you click through links we may earn a referral commission on qualifying purchases.
