If you enjoy baking with cherries, a reliable cherry pitter can save time, reduce mess, and help keep more fruit intact for pies, tarts, cobblers, jams, and canning. The best option for you depends on how many cherries you usually prep, how much storage space you have, and whether you prefer a compact handheld tool or a batch-friendly pitter.
For most bakers, the right cherry pitter makes cherry prep faster and less frustrating. This guide compares compact pitters, multi-cherry pitters, a suction-base countertop option, and a metal hand tool so you can choose the one that fits your kitchen routine.
This roundup is reader-supported. When you click through Amazon links, we may earn a referral commission on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Quick Verdict
Choose the OXO Good Grips Quick Release Multi Cherry Pitter if you bake or can with cherries often and want to pit several cherries at once. Pick the OXO Good Grips Cherry & Olive Pitter if you want a compact handheld tool that is easy to store. The Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Deluxe Cherry Pitter is a good fit if you prefer a suction-base countertop design.
Top Picks
- Best Overall for Baking Batches: OXO Good Grips Quick Release Multi Cherry Pitter
- Best Compact Option: OXO Good Grips Cherry & Olive Pitter – Black
- Best Suction-Base Pitter: Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Deluxe Cherry Pitter with Suction Base
- Best Durable Handheld Pitter: Westmark BCK34990 Cherry Pitter/Stoner
- Best Budget Multi-Cherry Option: SCHVUBENR 7-IN-1 Large Cherry Pitter Tool
How We Selected the Best Cherry Pitters
When choosing the best cherry pitters, we focused on practical buyer needs: how quickly each tool can pit cherries, how easy it is to control, whether it helps reduce splatter, how simple it is to clean, and whether the design fits common kitchen use. A good cherry pitter should remove the pit cleanly while keeping the fruit usable for baking, snacking, freezing, or preserving.
We also looked for clear use-case differences. A multi-cherry pitter makes sense for pies, jams, and canning. A compact handheld cherry and olive pitter is better for small kitchens and occasional use. A suction-base model can help if you want a more stable countertop setup.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Image | Best For | Highlights | Pros | Cons | CTA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OXO Good Grips Quick Release Multi Cherry Pitter |
 |
Batch baking, canning, and large bowls of cherries. | Pits up to six cherries at once and collects pits in a tray. | Fast for larger batches; useful when prepping cherries for pies or jam. | Larger than a handheld pitter and cherries still need to be positioned correctly. | Check Price on Amazon |
| OXO Good Grips Cherry & Olive Pitter |
 |
Small kitchens, quick snacks, and occasional baking. | Compact handheld design with a non-slip grip and splatter shield. | Easy to store; works for cherries and many olives. | Slower than a multi-pitter for full pie or jam batches. | Check Price on Amazon |
| Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Deluxe Cherry Pitter |
 |
Countertop use and steady repeated pitting. | Suction-base design helps keep the pitter in place during use. | Good for baking and canning prep; keeps both hands focused on the task. | Requires counter space and may work best when cherries are firm and well-positioned. | Check Price on Amazon |
| Westmark BCK34990 Cherry Pitter/Stoner |
 |
People who prefer a sturdy handheld cherry stoner. | Metal-style hand tool designed for simple cherry pitting. | Compact, durable-feeling design; simple to use without a large countertop setup. | Can expose your hands and counter to cherry juice if you work quickly. | Check Price on Amazon |
| SCHVUBENR 7-IN-1 Large Cherry Pitter Tool |
 |
Budget-minded buyers who want to try a multi-cherry pitter. | Designed to pit several cherries at once with a push-down layout. | Low-cost style; helpful for occasional batch prep. | Less proven than longer-established options, so check current buyer feedback before purchasing. | Check Price on Amazon |
Before You Buy a Cherry Pitter
- Choose single or multi-cherry capacity: A handheld pitter is fine for snacks and small desserts. A multi-pitter is better for pie filling, freezing, canning, and jam.
- Check cherry size compatibility: Very small, soft, oversized, or uneven cherries may not line up perfectly in every pitter.
- Expect some mess: A splatter shield, pit tray, or countertop setup can help, but cherry juice can still stain surfaces.
- Think about cleanup: If you pit cherries often, look for designs that open easily or are listed as dishwasher safe on the current product page.
- Inspect the fruit after pitting: No cherry pitter is perfect. Always check for missed pits before serving cherries to children or using them in baked goods.
OXO Good Grips Quick Release Multi Cherry Pitter
The OXO Good Grips Quick Release Multi Cherry Pitter is the strongest fit if you usually bake with more than a handful of cherries. Instead of pitting one cherry at a time, it is designed to pit up to six cherries per press, which makes it more practical for pies, cobblers, freezing, and canning prep.
The pit collection tray helps keep your workspace cleaner, and the wide press-style design is easier to use for batch work than many small handheld tools. You still need to load the cherries properly and check for missed pits, but this is the option most likely to save time when you are working through a bowl of fruit.
Best For
- Cherry pies, cobblers, jams, and canning projects
- Families who prep large bowls of fresh cherries
- Anyone who wants a faster alternative to single-cherry pitting
Why You’ll Like It
- Pits up to six cherries at once
- Includes a pit tray to help control cleanup
- Useful for bigger baking and preserving batches
What to Consider
This is not the smallest option in the guide. If you only pit a few cherries at a time or have very limited drawer space, a compact handheld pitter may be easier to store.
OXO Good Grips Cherry & Olive Pitter – Black
The OXO Good Grips Cherry & Olive Pitter is the easiest recommendation if you want a compact, simple tool for everyday cherry prep. It is designed with a pressure-absorbing, non-slip grip and a removable splatter shield, which helps reduce mess when you are pitting cherries for yogurt, salads, desserts, or quick snacks.
This model is slower than a multi-cherry pitter, but it is easier to store and more convenient for small amounts of fruit. It can also be useful if you want one tool that can handle cherries and many olives, as long as the fruit fits the pitter opening.
Best For
- Small kitchens and limited drawer space
- Occasional cherry baking and snacking
- People who also want an olive pitter
Why You’ll Like It
- Compact handheld design
- Non-slip grip for better control
- Removable splatter shield helps limit juice mess
What to Consider
If you regularly pit several pounds of cherries, this handheld design will take more time than a multi-cherry pitter. For large batches, choose a higher-capacity model.
Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Deluxe Cherry Pitter
The Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Deluxe Cherry Pitter is a good match if you like the idea of a countertop cherry pitter with a suction base. The suction base is meant to help hold the tool steady while you work, which can make repetitive pitting feel more controlled than using a small handheld tool.
This style is especially useful for baking and canning prep because you can work through cherries in a repeated motion. It is also a practical choice if you do not want to squeeze a handheld pitter over and over. For best results, use firm cherries, position them carefully, and check the finished fruit for missed pits.
Best For
- Countertop cherry prep
- Bakers who want a more stable setup
- People who prefer not to use a squeeze-style handheld pitter
Why You’ll Like It
- Suction base helps add stability during use
- Designed for repeated cherry pitting
- Useful for baking, canning, and fresh cherry prep
What to Consider
This type of pitter takes more counter space than a handheld tool. The suction base also needs a clean, smooth surface to work well.
Westmark BCK34990 Cherry Pitter/Stoner
The Westmark BCK34990 Cherry Pitter/Stoner is a strong pick if you prefer a simple handheld cherry stoner with a sturdy, traditional feel. It is a compact alternative to larger countertop pitters, so it makes sense for people who want a durable-feeling tool without giving up much storage space.
This model is best for steady manual pitting rather than high-speed batch processing. It can work well for baking and snacking, but you may want to pit cherries over a bowl or cutting board because juice can splatter or stain while you work.
Best For
- People who prefer a sturdy handheld tool
- Small-batch baking and fresh cherry snacks
- Kitchens where drawer storage matters
Why You’ll Like It
- Compact hand-tool design
- Good option if you want a simple cherry stoner
- No large countertop base to store
What to Consider
This is a manual single-cherry style, so it will not be as fast as a multi-cherry pitter for large batches. Wear an apron or work over a protected surface if cherry stains are a concern.
SCHVUBENR 7-IN-1 Large Cherry Pitter Tool
The SCHVUBENR 7-IN-1 Large Cherry Pitter Tool is the budget-minded multi-cherry option in this guide. It is designed to pit several cherries at once, which can make it appealing if you want to speed up cherry prep without choosing one of the higher-priced or more established designs.
This is best for occasional batch use, such as prepping cherries for a pie, a small jam project, or a family snack bowl. Because it appears to be a newer and less proven option than some of the other picks, check the current Amazon listing, recent buyer feedback, return policy, and product photos before buying.
Best For
- Budget-conscious buyers
- Occasional cherry baking and snack prep
- People who want to try a multi-cherry pitter design
Why You’ll Like It
- Designed to pit several cherries at once
- Push-down layout can save time for small batches
- Simple option for occasional cherry season use
What to Consider
Plastic multi-pitters can vary in durability and alignment. If you plan to pit cherries often every season, compare this carefully with the more established OXO multi-pitter before deciding.
FAQ
What Should I Consider When Buying a Cherry Pitter?
Think about how often you pit cherries and how many you prep at once. If you mostly snack on cherries or bake occasionally, a compact handheld cherry pitter is usually enough. If you make pies, jams, cobblers, or canned cherries, a multi-cherry pitter can save more time. Also consider cleanup, storage size, splatter control, and whether the tool can handle the cherry sizes you usually buy.
Is a Multi-Cherry Pitter Better Than a Handheld Pitter?
A multi-cherry pitter is better for larger batches because it can pit several cherries per press. A handheld pitter is better for small amounts, quick snacks, and compact storage. If you bake with cherries often, choose a multi-pitter. If you only pit a few cherries at a time, choose a handheld model.
Can I Use a Cherry Pitter for Olives?
Some cherry pitters can also work for olives, especially models sold as cherry and olive pitters. The main limitation is size. Large olives may not fit smaller cherry pitters, so check the current product details before relying on one tool for both cherries and olives.
How Do I Use a Cherry Pitter Effectively?
Wash and dry the cherries first. Place each cherry stem-side up or in the position recommended by the manufacturer. Press firmly and evenly so the plunger passes through the center of the fruit. Keep one bowl for pitted cherries and another for pits. After pitting, inspect the cherries by hand because any pitter can miss a pit.
Are Cherry Pitters Easy to Clean?
Many cherry pitters are designed to rinse clean, and some are listed as dishwasher safe. Designs with pit trays, shields, or several moving parts may need more careful cleaning. Always check the current manufacturer care instructions before placing a pitter in the dishwasher.
What Is the Best Cherry Pitter for Baking?
For baking, the best cherry pitter is usually the one that matches your batch size. For one pie or repeated baking projects, a multi-cherry pitter such as the OXO Good Grips Quick Release Multi Cherry Pitter is the most convenient. For occasional desserts, the compact OXO Good Grips Cherry & Olive Pitter is easier to store.
Wrapping Up
A quality cherry pitter can make cherry season easier, especially if you bake, freeze, can, or make jam. For larger batches, choose a multi-cherry pitter that helps you move through fruit faster. For everyday snacking or small desserts, a compact handheld pitter is simple and easy to store. No matter which style you choose, always check pitted cherries before serving or baking to avoid missed pits.
This Roundup is reader-supported. When you click through links we may earn a referral commission on qualifying purchases.
